Category Archives: Immunology

Scombroid Poisoning

Differential diagnosis to allergy. Basically Histamine poisoning, rather than release of endogenous stores! Mild examples are not uncommon but severe cases rare. Clue is that several people who eat the same seafood meal fall ill with similar allergic symptoms!

Histamine and other amines are produced by bacteria from certain amino acids (can occur during production eg Swiss cheese or by spoilage). Particularly affects fish of the Scombridae family (viz tuna, mahi mahi, bluefish, sardines, mackerel, amberjack, and abalone) but can be any food containing the right amino acids and subject to the right bacterial enzymes.

Fish/shellfish allergy

Seafood as a term includes fish and shellfish. Shellfish usually refers both to crustaceans and molluscs, even though some molluscs don’t have shells (octopus/squid, for example), so not the best term.

But allergy to one does not imply allergy to the other! In fact, shellfish allergy is linked strongly to house dust mite allergy rather than fish, probably since they are all invetebrates with the same sort of Tropomysins.  Co-sensitivity is relatively common (20-40% of fish allergic also allergic to shellfish) so must simply be atopic disposition!

Chordata (finned fish) subdivide roughly into bottom feeders, mackerel/tuna [perciformes] group, salmon/trout [salmoniformes] group and the rest (so called “bony fish”) but this doesn’t mean much in allergy terms.  The best studied allergen Gad c1, found in cod, is a parvalbumin.  These are found in muscle, esp slow twitch white flesh (cf dark muscled, fast fish eg tuna, swordfish).    At least 50% of those with allergy to one type of  fish will be allergic to another; there are no good predictors for this. Cod allergy typically means allergy to herring, plaice and mackerel but not great published evidence. Anaphylaxis UK and Allergy UK do not discuss cross reactivity at all (risk of cross contamination, of course). “White fish” is used as a grouping but doesn’t really have much biological meaning (and confusing because there is a N American white fleshed fish called whitefish…).

The rate of cross reactivity between different kinds of shellfish/molluscs is high since there is less variation in tropomysins.

Shellfish (crustaceans) are related to molluscs including abalone, clam, mussel, squid, octopus.  Allergy to these is more common in countries where these are commonly eaten viz Spain, Japan – which is not surprising when you think about it, although typically surprising to the people who live there.

Sneaky places you find seafood:

  • Soups eg bouillabaisse
  • Pate
  • Seafood “crab” sticks – usually fish, not crab!
  • Worcestershire sauce (anchovy)
  • Pizza (anchovy)
  • Caesar salad (anchovy)

Reactions to seafood may not be allergic:

  • Anisakis is fish parasite, worldwide distribution, with a range of different allergens.  Larvae can cause immediate allergic response, but infection can also produce inflammatory symptoms of varying kinds, depending on where in the digestive tract the larvae are deposited.
  • Scombroid toxicity esp associated with salmon, tuna, mackerel.  Besides flushing, vomiting and wheezing, there can be severe headache and dizziness.  Onset is minutes to hours.
  • Ciguatoxin poisoning associated with reef fish eg sea bass, snapper.  Onset is slower – 30 minutes to hours, besides cramps, D+V there can be myalgia and paraesthesiae.
  • Shellfish (mostly bivalves) can be the source of a range of toxins with effects as diverse as paraesthesia, myalgia, ataxia, even seizures.   Mostly D+V though.

Cod IgE >20 gives 95% PPV, other cut offs lacking.  IgE>8 (>5 for salmon) predicts objective symptoms and non tolerance (cf partial tolerance).

Given importance of omega 3, unnecessary restriction should be avoided – Canning fish reduces immunogenicity, challenge?  Interestingly, many fish allergens seem to get MORE allergenic with heating, not less – Gad c 1 is known to become airborne in steam without denaturing! Various cases of fatal anaphylaxis simply to inhaling vapour of frying fish (aerosolised proteins, NOT smell, that causes reaction).

[JACI 2017 letter – small numbers though]

Food additives and allergy

Sorbic acid used as preservative.  Very low level of toxicity, as rapidly metabolized (a fatty acid).  A few reports of contact dermatitis and pseudo-allergy only.

Similarly with Tartrazine, MSG, Benzoate – in most children, there is very limited evidence for any role of food additives in causing non-allergic food hypersensitivity. Reactions may be more common in children with chronic urticaria and angioedema.  While other symptoms including migraine, gastrointestinal disturbances and arthralgia have been attributed to food additives, there are no reproducible and consistent data from DBPC studies to support this.

Natural additives eg Annatto can also cause problems in some patients!

Sulphites (sulfites, eg sodium metabisulfite) and natural salicylates may cause skin (usually contact dermatitis, but can be angioedema), GI, respiratory problems (even anaphylaxis) but these are best termed adverse reactions as they have a pharmacological basis.  Patch and IgE test available, however.  Very common in our food – in fresh foods to control browning, soft drinks, dried foods (as preservative), wine and beer.  Yet very rare in childhood and therefore hard to spot.  Also seen in in anaesthetic solutions, antibiotics, adrenaline (!!!), cosmetics.  Sulphites can have effects when used topically, orally or parenterally – mostly seen in those with asthma.  Can be acute or chronic.  Given the problem with using adrenaline, may need to be treated with steroids, antihistamines, bronchodilators instead! [Clinical & Experimental Allergy. 39(11):1643-51, 2009 PMID 19775253]  

Salicylates are a large group of assorted foods and other things that can cause problems including anaphylaxis.  Natural salicylates are generally acetylated so no need to automatically avoid them if intolerance to aspirin/NSAIDs.

[PJ Turner, J Paeds Child health 2010]

Pregnancy and nut allergy

No increased risk of peanut allergy with antenatal intake or intake during breast feeding, or with infant intake (Fox, J Allergy Clin Immunol. 2009 Feb;123(2):417-23). But did find dose response with household intake, esp peanut butter – so avoid!?

10 000 mums in US, not high risk, Eating Peanuts/Tree Nuts ≥5 times vs <1 time per month in their peripregnancy diet reduced risk of allergy by 2/3: odds ratio = 0.31; 95% CI, 0.13-0.75; Ptrend = .004). [Lindsay Frazier JAMA Pediatr. 2014;168(2):156-162. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2013.4139]

60 000 mums in Danish National Birth Cohort, those eating peanuts and treenuts at least once weekly had kids with less asthma (OR 0.66), tree nuts also appeared to protect against rhinitis.

1200 US mums (not high risk) Higher maternal peanut intake (each additional z score) during the first trimester was associated with 47% reduced odds of peanut allergic reaction (odds ratio [OR], 0.53; 95% CI, 0.30-0.94).[J Allergy Clin Imm Volume 133, Issue 5, May 2014, Pages 1373–1382. DOI: 10.1016/j.jaci.2013.11.040]

Erythema multiforme

Consists of well-circumscribed target-like lesions most commonly on the extremities. In about half of cases the cause is never found. Causes include:

Stevens Johnson Syndrome and Toxic Epidermal Necrolysis

Closely related. Characteristically severe, diffuse mucocutaneous eruption with atypical flat target lesions, irregular, possibly purpuric, blistering, even haemorrhagic! Painful, like sunburn.  Different pathology from Erythema multiforme! Evolve over 1-2 weeks, subside over further 2-3 weeks.

Other manifestations are fever (prodromal illness can manifest as URTI).  Mucosal lesions (stomatitis, conjunctivitis/blepharitis, or genital inflammation) accompanied by at least 1 other visceral organ, such as hepatic, renal, trach/bronchial or gastrointestinal involvement. Urethral involvement can cause retention of urine. Chest and abdominal signs pretty common!

Urgent ophthalmology – uveitis can lead to blindness.

Beer allergy

Well described, mostly due to a non-specific lipid transport protein (LTP) so likely to find various co-sensitivities.  Some will be wheat, barley, maize, rice, yeast etc positive but history likely to be suggestive.  Consider hops, metabisulphites.  Malting, filtration etc probably affects allergenicity.  Presence of alcohol may enhance absorption?  In the case below, maize LTP eventually identified but patient could eat polenta and popcorn!

But individual beers vary in their allergenicity, and skin prick testing can reveal types that are safe! Hoegaarden in this report – Allergy 2012:67;1186