Shared Decision Making

[NICE guidance 2021] See also participatory medicine and family centred care.

First bullet point is that this should be embedded at organisational level! Includes:

  • provide access to patient decision aids (PDAs) or information about risks and benefits
  • review how “information systems” might help record discussions and decisions, for example through patient held record
  • prompt patients (through media, posters, letters) to ask questions about options, and “making the decision that’s right for me

Staff training:

  • evidence based model eg three-talk model (introduce choice, describe options, help explore preferences and make decision)
  • communication skills – avoiding jargon, explaining technical terms
  • communicating with families and others the patient would like involved

Note that NHS England has “accessible information standards”.

In practice:

  • Agree an agenda
  • Ensure the person understands they can take part as fully as they want in making choices about their treatment or care
  • When it comes to tests or treatments, explain what the health care aim is of each option, and discuss how that might align with patients “aims, priorities and wider goals”
  • chunk and check information
  • check understanding eg teach back
  • Give information away at time of discussion or very soon after, including contact details
  • Write letters to the patient rather than to their doctor, in line with 2018 Academy of Medical Royal Colleges’ guidance on writing outpatient clinic letters to patients (or at least a copy to patient, unless they expressly don’t want to receive any written information).

Communicating risk:

  • Make clear how information applies to them personally, and how much uncertainty applies
  • Use mixture of numbers, pictograms and “icon arrays” (repeated icons, with different colours, to see proportions), to allow people to see both positive AND negative framing
  • Be aware that different people interpret terms such as ‘risk’, ‘rare’, ‘unusual’ and ‘common’ in different ways
  • Use absolute risk rather than relative risk. For example, the risk of an event increases from 1 in 1,000 to 2 in 1,000, rather than the risk of the event doubles.
  • Use 10 in 100, rather than 10%
  • Use the same denominator
  • State both positive and negative framing